|
By: Beth English, CAA - Rumson-Fair Haven Regional High School It's a strange and somewhat disappointing feeling to be sitting in my office, writing out these thoughts about sports. I love being an athletic director because I've always loved being a teammate and later in life a coach. I cherished the often-overlooked moments—those quiet, in-between spaces that defined the experience far more than any scoreboard ever could. Not every moment was positive, beneficial, or life-changing in the traditional sense. But when I think back on my time as an athlete and my career as a coach, my soul is lifted. It's not the wins, records, or titles that stand out. It's the hugs after tough losses, the tears in the locker room, the late-night bus rides, the inside jokes—the moments where I had nothing left to give but gave anyway. As an adult, when I see my old teammates, all it takes is one conversation to bring us right back to the court. We feel 17 again, because the connection we built decades ago was real, positive, and deeply meaningful. As a former coach, standing at the wedding of a former athlete, someone who once trusted me to be their rock through their most formative years, I'm reminded of why I'm still in this profession. It's not the trophies—it's the relationships, growth, and reflection. It's about creating something bigger than yourself and getting people to buy into it. Now, as an athletic director, my reach is the furthest it can ever be. I feel overwhelmed, caught in what feels like a losing battle to return to the true purpose of sports. Somewhere along the way, our culture shifted and we stopped prioritizing those things. I played in the late '90s. Even then, there were distractions—ego, jealousy, greed. Those things have always been part of the human condition. But now, they're no longer in the background; they're front and center. Social media, external pressures, and a results-driven mindset have created a culture where the joy of the game, the purpose of the team, and the lessons of adversity often get lost. I find myself asking: Will today's athletes and coaches feel what we felt? Will they look back and remember the moments that truly mattered? My heart wants to say yes. Toxic Sports Culture: How Education-Based Athletics Are Suffering Education-based athletics, school sports, are supposed to be about the journey: building relationships, learning life lessons, navigating adversity, and growing as individuals, teammates, and communities. But today, these programs are struggling, caught between two powerful, money-driven forces: monetized youth sports and results-oriented college/professional pipelines. Once youth sports became a billion-dollar industry, everything changed. What used to be about play, development, and joy morphed into performance, exposure, and winning at all costs. The old problem of overzealous parents living vicariously through their kids was replaced by something even more damaging: a manufactured, high-pressure environment where children are expected to train like professionals before they even hit puberty. Nowhere is this felt more acutely than in high school sports. These programs are increasingly sandwiched between club systems that promise scholarships (for a price) and college recruiters seeking the next phenom or NILs. The result? Burnout, broken confidence, injuries, and a mental health crisis. Kids aren't quitting because they've stopped loving the game. They're quitting because the game stopped loving them back. When youth sports become about money, rankings, and production, we rob kids of what they came for—joy, connection, and growth. They have their whole lives to stress about performance and pressure. Let them be kids now. Their minds and hearts aren't built for adult expectations, and they shouldn't have to be. A pivotal moment in this shift came with the rise of “daddy ball.” When a child wasn't good enough to make a competitive team, the solution wasn't to work harder or develop further; it was to start a new team. One where the pecking order was predetermined, and sport IQ took a backseat to personal ego. This diluted competition warped the concept of merit, teaching young athletes that being the best on your team—even if that team exists just to spotlight you—is more important than truly growing as a player or person. We've created a rat race out of amateur sports. In doing so, we've lost the core values that made school sports a meaningful part of education. Until we restore the emphasis on development, community, and the holistic well-being of athletes, this toxic culture will persist and continue to harm the very kids it claims to support. The Shift of Specialization Another key moment in the decline of education-based athletics was the push for early specialization. Gone are the days when kids played multiple sports, experienced different team cultures, learned from a variety of coaches, and developed well-rounded athleticism—not to mention perspective and resilience. When athletes compete in different sports, they learn more than just physical skills. They learn how to learn—how to adapt to different leadership styles, how to handle being a role player on one team and a star on another. They gain humility, versatility, and emotional intelligence. They learn what to emulate from good coaches, and just as important, what not to repeat from bad ones. This diversity of experience builds character. But somewhere along the way, we decided that in order to be “great,” kids needed to pick one sport, play it year-round, and chase scholarships like it was a job. We replaced play with pressure. We called it commitment when, in fact, it was burnout in disguise. Lost Lessons of Sport: We Need to Facilitate, Not Fix At the same time, competition lost its meaning. It used to be a healthy source of self-motivation—a way to push yourself, measure growth, and strive for excellence. Now, too often, competition is treated like a threat—a reason to blame others, make excuses, and avoid adversity rather than grow from it. Instead of helping kids navigate disappointment, many adults try to remove it entirely. Rather than facilitate improvement through hard conversations, we try to protect them from discomfort. But real development happens in the struggle; in the car ride home after a tough practice, at the dinner table after a bad game. And kids are watching—your words, tone, and body language. They absorb it all. If your first response to a bad game is to blame the coach, the referee, or another player, your child learns to deflect rather than reflect. They learn that criticism is an attack, not a tool; that accountability is optional. Over time, that robs them of joy. Supporting your child doesn't mean defending them against every hardship. It doesn't mean hating the coach or undermining the team. That's not support, that's distraction. That's ego. That's noise. True support means walking alongside them through the ups and downs. Letting them struggle. Letting them grow. Sports, at their best, aren't just about winning—they're about becoming. "Comparison is the Thief of Joy, But Growth is the Key to the Journey" In athletics, it's easy to fall into the trap of comparison. For instance, measuring our value or success against someone else's stats, playing time, or athleticism. But as Theodore Roosevelt said, “Comparison is the thief of joy.” It pulls focus away from the most important part of this experience: personal growth. Education-based athletics is not recreational. This environment comes with structure, standards, and competition – including the fight for roster spots and playing time. That doesn't make it unkind or unfair. It means it's an opportunity for kids to learn accountability, discipline, and self-reflection in real, meaningful ways. When a player gets cut or doesn't earn the playing time they hoped for, it can feel like failure. But it's actually a fork in the road and a powerful moment for growth. The question isn't just, “Why didn't I make it?” It's, “Do I want to work harder for this, or is there another path where I'll find more joy?” Both answers are valid. Not everyone wants the commitment and intensity that comes with competitive athletics, and that's okay. Recreational leagues, other clubs, or even non-sport passions may be a better fit. What matters most is helping kids ask the right questions:
We must teach young athletes that self-worth isn't defined by where they land on a depth chart. Their attention should be on who they become through the process. Let's help them measure progress by effort, attitude, and resilience, not just minutes played or honors received. The Ripple Effect: When Fans Become Part of the Problem It's not just the athletes who are affected by this toxic shift in sports culture. It's also their peers in the stands who grow up in the same environment of misplaced priorities and modeled negativity. The impact is clear: students today often don't know how to cheer for their team without tearing the other side down. Instead of lifting their peers through positive support, the default form of “cheering” is often ridicule, taunts, personal attacks, and social media jabs that don't end when the final buzzer sounds. Again, this isn't happening in a vacuum—it's learned behavior. Many adults in the stands either silently tolerate it or actively encourage it. The message becomes as long as we win, the behavior doesn't matter. I've been in gyms where a home basketball player hits a beautiful shot, nothing but net, and it's met with silence. But when an opponent steps to the free-throw line, the entire student section suddenly comes alive—not to cheer on their team, but to shout the name of the kid's girlfriend in hopes of distracting him. Can you imagine trying to play in that environment? God forbid you airball, because then it doesn't end on the court. It follows you to Snapchat, Instagram, or TikTok. The arena is now digital, and the cruelty is louder than ever. Sportsmanship sitting at an all-time low is not a tough argument to make, and adults are again at the center of the blame. You don't believe me? Go to a youth soccer tournament, a travel baseball league, or a 5th grade basketball game. Adults are yelling on the sideline like it's Game 7 of the NBA finals. No one is safe, either. Officials, opposing players, coaches, and other fans are all targets. Whether by fueling the fire or refusing to extinguish it, we've allowed this behavior to thrive. We've confused “school spirit” with humiliation. We've accepted disrespect as part of the game. If we want sports to actually teach values, build character—not just competitors—we must expect more from everyone, not just the players. The culture we allow in the stands is the same culture our athletes absorb on the court. We need to teach kids how to win with humility and lose with grace. How to compete hard but respect the opponent. And most of all, how to create an environment where everyone, athletes and fans alike, can grow through sport. Where Do We Go From Here? We don't need to go back in time, it takes intentionality about where we go next.
We must ask ourselves: Are we creating systems that develop athletes, or damage them? Are we helping kids become better players, or better people? This culture won't shift overnight. But it starts with us:
The Paradox of it All Here's the rub for those who only chase results: I get it. Winning matters. I've felt the pride of championships, records, and hard-earned success. But with all the years and games behind me, one truth has never changed. When you focus on the right things, discipline, character, preparation, and accountability, success takes care of itself. It's no coincidence the teams that win off the field—in the classroom, weight room, and community—are the same ones who win under the lights. The habits you build when no one is watching. They shape the results everyone sees. That connection is real. It's what turns potential into performance. Because winning doesn't start at kickoff—it starts long before the whistle ever blows. If we want to reclaim the purpose of educational athletics, we must return to its roots: relationship, growth, community, and joy. The joy of sports, the real joy, isn't found on a scoreboard. It's in the hard conversations, the moments of doubt, the silent head nods after a tough practice, the uncontrollable laughter on the bus, the support we give each other, and the unbreakable bonds formed when you push through something hard, together. That's what I remember. That's what I hope today's athletes remember, too. Let's fight to make sure they do—before it's too late. When sports aren't building something better, a real opportunity is missed for everyone involved.
|
![Reclaiming the Heart of Sports [NIAAA]](https://d32hqtdnadtdcp.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/NIAAA-ARTICLE-09-2026.png)


