Coaches Insider
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Log In
  • Sign Up Free
  • Baseball
  • Basketball
    • Men’s Basketball
    • Women’s Basketball
  • Football
  • Lacrosse
  • Soccer
  • Softball
  • Track & X-Country
  • Volleyball
  • Wrestling
  • ADInsider
Navigation
  • Baseball Home
  • Skills & Drills
  • Strategy
  • Topics
  • Shop
  • Infield Manual Course
  • CLINICS & CONFERENCES
  • INSIDER +PLUS
The Mental Approach to Coaching

The Mental Approach to Coaching

May 13, 2025 • By Adam Sarancik

By: Adam Sarancik

Author of: Coaching Champions for Life

"When evaluating your team, look first in the mirror with honest intent."

What is your mental approach to coaching? By your mental approach, I'm not asking about the approach you take to coaching the mental side of your player's game. I'm talking about your mental approach to your own coaching and the approach of your assistant coaches to their own coaching.

All good coaches know the critical importance of the mental side of training, competing and, in fact, for everything in life. It is both an essential component to elite development and the edge and difference maker in competition. All good coaches pay regular and very specific attention to developing the mind of their players, e.g., mental toughness, tenacity, focus, relaxation and positivity. Those coaches constantly address the "mental approach" that will best handle the moment, e.g., the game situation, an opponent, etc.

I wrote a book, Coaching Champions for Life, which discusses in great detail the general mental approach to coaching. Specifically, what I am asking here is when mistakes happen in a game, for example, what are the very first thoughts that come to your mind and to the minds of your assistant coaches?

We all see and hear coaches immediately bark rebukes at their players when mistakes happen. Why do they do that? Is it as simple as their coaches did it to them when they were players so they have been conditioned to do it to their players? Is it a release of anxiety on their part for some self-imposed pressure such as their need to "win"? Do they actually think it will immediately translate to better mechanics and play of their players? Do they really believe telling is teaching? (It's not.)

Here's my philosophy. There are only two types of games; well played and a failure of coaching. When mistakes happen, they're the fault of the coaches - period. When a player makes a physical error or when the team fails to handle a situation properly; it is the fault of the coaches, not the players. No other "mental approach" to coaching will lead to optimum results in the short or long-term.

Championship coaches, teams and programs are built by coaches who recognize the importance of "looking first in the mirror with honest intent."  When mistakes happen, coaches must immediately and intently reflect upon the ways they failed to properly train the player(s) so that the error would not happen.  What are the weak links in our training of preparation, anticipation, reaction and action of that player and of our team?

The philosophy of "get better every day" applies first and foremost to the coaches.  The mindset of our own accountability for every mistake our players make must be trained into our psyche to be not just a habit; it must be an instinct.

Players are required to have and can be held immediately accountable for having these things: a teachable spirit, their best effort, a growth mindset and an unfailing commitment to the maximum development of themselves and the team.  They can and must be held accountable for all of these things.  But failing to do these things are not mistakes.  They are matters of character. Coaches can exemplify, train and mentor these things too, of course, but players should be called out immediately for failing in any of these areas.

What I am advocating here is a change in the long-standing custom of coaches being reflexively, vocally critical of their players when mistakes happen rather than recognizing and considering that the primary cause of the error was a failure of coaching methodology. It is sadly too easy for a coach to use their position of power to criticize a player for their mistakes. This habit will not change the mechanics of the player in the short-term and will not set an example of how to handle problems in life in the long-term outside of the sport.

During games, we see coaches keeping several notebooks of meticulous data about the play of their team and their opponent. Who is keeping book on the performance of the coaches? I think if coaches put as much effort into evaluating their own methodology and approaches as they do their players, they would win more championships and, more importantly, they would develop more Champions for Life.

Adam Sarancik is the Author of Four Amazon Top 100 Best Selling Baseball Coaching Books:

  • Coaching Champions for Life – The Process of Mentoring the Person, Athlete and Player
  • Takeaway Quotes for Coaching Champions for Life
  • A Ground Ball to Shortstop – How and Why Coaches See Their Game Differently Than Anyone Else.
  • Teacher, Role Model, Mentor: Lessons Learned From a Lifetime in Coaching.

 

MyNotes () Leave a Comment (0 Comments)

More from Adam Sarancik View all from Adam Sarancik

Tips and Guidelines for Communication and Teaching Methodology to Protect Mental Health

Tips and Guidelines for Communication and Teaching Methodology to Protect Mental Health

Holistic Coaching for the Benefit of All Players

Holistic Coaching for the Benefit of All Players

Do Not Confuse Bad Swing Path with Bad Timing

Do Not Confuse Bad Swing Path with Bad Timing

A Hard Conversation

A Hard Conversation

Primary Sidebar

Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
You are on the list!

Become an Insider!
Get our latest Baseball content delivered straight to your inbox!

Latest Content

  • Hitting: Flip Drills with Caleb Longley – Texas A&M Univ.

    Hitting: Flip Drills with Caleb Longley – Texas A&M Univ.

  • Pitching: Mound Visit Tips with Jason Jackson – Univ. of Alabama

    Pitching: Mound Visit Tips with Jason Jackson – Univ. of Alabama

  • The Mental Approach to Coaching

    The Mental Approach to Coaching

  • Developing Pitch Recognition with Jay Johnson – Louisiana State Univ.

    Developing Pitch Recognition with Jay Johnson – Louisiana State Univ.

  • Infielders’ Double Play Footwork with Tracy Archuleta – Indiana State Univ.

    Infielders’ Double Play Footwork with Tracy Archuleta – Indiana State Univ.

  • Using HHB Data to Create Competition with Larry Vucan – Carroll High School (TX)

    Using HHB Data to Create Competition with Larry Vucan – Carroll High School (TX)

  • About Us
  • FAQ
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • © Copyright 2025 Clell Wade Coaches Directory, Inc., All Rights Reserved.

  • Sign Up Free
  • Home
  • Log In
  • Cart
  • ADInsider
  • Baseball
  • Basketball
    • Men’s Basketball
    • Women’s Basketball
    • Back
  • Football
  • Lacrosse
  • Soccer
  • Softball
  • Track & X-Country
  • Volleyball
  • Wrestling
  • About Us
  • Contact Us